Council of State (Judicial Division) – Section VII – Judgment No. 7956 of November 2, 2026 – Presiding Judge Di Carlo, Reporting Judge Rotondano.
The Council of State upheld the appeal filed by the City of Capri against Judgment No. 6796/2025 of the Campania Regional Administrative Court, which had overturned the city’s denial of a maritime state concession requested by a company that owns a bar-restaurant in an area designated by regional regulations for the launching and hauling of small boats.
The Company, whose position was endorsed by the Regional Administrative Court, argued that the land-use designations assigned to the various areas of the port by the regulations could be waived, pursuant to a regulatory provision that allows activities to be carried out within the port upon submission of a SCIA to the competent authorities.
The Council of State, noting that the literal wording of the regional regulation confers a mandatory nature on the land-use designations specified therein, observed that the regulatory provision applied by the Regional Administrative Court to support the possibility of derogating from those designations—which expressly refers to Article 68 of the Navigation Code—simply allows private individuals to carry out business and nautical activities in general, without, however, providing for the municipality’s authority to grant state-owned areas for exclusive use—an authority that derives from the separate Article 36 of the Navigation Code.
It follows that the municipality’s denial is legitimate, as this measure is subject to the regional planning provisions on which it is based.
